C# cannot declare a named property with parameters: only the type's
default member gets indexer syntax, and reusing it via [IndexerName]
collapses for types with several differently-named indexed properties,
static properties, or explicit interface implementations. Emitting the
accessors as ordinary methods is the only fully general compilable
form, matches how C# consumes such properties (Roslyn exposes the
accessors of properties it cannot bind as regular methods, the same
pattern C# 14 made user-facing for extension-member disambiguation),
and round-trips call sites to identical IL. Call sites already lower
to direct accessor calls.
The property-level attributes are kept on the first accessor under the
'property:' attribute target: it is not valid on methods, so csc emits
nothing for it (CS0657 warning) and recompilation neither loses the
attributes from the source nor misapplies them to the accessor. A
comment on the first accessor documents the deliberate deviation.
Visual Studio's metadata-as-source view drops such properties'
attributes entirely.
The assembly tree and tooltips are unaffected: they keep rendering the
property node with its parameter list. Known limitation, inherent to
any C# projection: recompiling the output produces plain methods, so
VB.NET consumers of the recompiled assembly lose property syntax.
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-fable-5:Claude Code
Siegfried Pammer