The PdbGen tests compared the reconstructed PDB to the C# compiler's
byte-for-byte, so any non-trivial method failed on reconstructed IL
ranges, hidden sequence points and local scopes - none of which the
decompiler can reproduce exactly. That left four of seven fixtures
[Ignore]d and the suite with almost no coverage.
Compare only what a debugging user actually feels: the visible (non-hidden)
breakpoint map, parsed straight from the sequence-point blobs and keyed by
method-definition row (shared between the PDB and the PE it describes). IL
offsets, hidden points, local scopes and the embedded source are dropped.
The compiler's own PDB is the oracle, so the tests assert correct debugging
behavior rather than the decompiler's past output. Methods where the
decompiler legitimately diverges pin an auto-derived residual snapshot, the
same accept-the-diff workflow as the pretty tests; a separate oracle-free
check rejects duplicate or overlapping sequence points.
Un-ignores ForLoopTests, LambdaCapturing and Members (its source is
regenerated to match the decompiler's per-type output, collapsing ~50 lines
of indentation-induced coordinate noise to two genuine differences).
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-4-8:Claude Code
Compilation uses the .NET builds of the Roslyn toolsets (tasks/netcore*,
bincore csc.dll/vbc.dll launched through the dotnet host). ilasm/ildasm
options use the '-' prefix, which all platforms accept. The dotnet-hosted
compilers have no implicit references or SDK path: net40 compiles pass
mscorlib explicitly, and vbc gets -sdkpath, _MYTYPE=Empty and
-vbruntime:Microsoft.VisualBasic.Core.dll (the facade in the ref packs is
not followed for runtime helpers). The TestRunner gets a self-contained
build for the host platform.
Configurations depending on Windows-only tools or runtimes (legacy
csc/vbc, Roslyn 1.x/2.x, mcs, Force32Bit, executing net40 binaries) are
filtered from the matrix off-Windows via Tester.SupportedOnCurrentPlatform
or gated with [Platform("Win")]. PdbGen comparisons normalize document
name separators, and Correctness/Async uses Console.IsInputRedirected
instead of the Windows-only Console.CapsLock.
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-fable-5:Claude Code
The portable-PDB writer carried its knobs (no-logo, pdb id, progress,
progress title) as a growing list of optional WritePdb parameters.
Turn the type into a configured instance whose options are properties,
and add EmbedSourceFiles (default true): when a PDB is generated next
to a project export whose .cs are already on disk, embedding the source
again is redundant, so the caller can turn it off. The per-document
checksum/hash is computed either way, so documents still resolve.
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-4-8:Claude Code
This commit adds a new parameter to PortablePdbWriter.WritePdb that
allows the caller to provide an implementation of IProgress to receive
status updates on the pdb generation process. Currently, the progress
reports include the number of files generated so far and the total
number of files.
This commit adds a new parameter to PortablePdbWriter.WritePdb that
allows the caller to specify the exact Guid and timestamp that should be
used in the generated PDB. This will be useful for several scenarios
that are interesting for the Visual Studio debugger's integration:
1. Generating a PDB for an assembly that was built without debug info.
The PDB writer currently fails in this case, since the input assembly
has no debug directory from which to extract the relevant info. The
debugger can provide values that will allow us to load the generated
PDB.
2. Generating a PDB for an assembly that has multiple debug directories.
The PDB writer currently uses the first debug directory it finds, but
this isn't necessarily the correct one. The debugger can provide the
correct values.
Siegfried Pammer
Peter Crabtree
Christoph Wille
Kirill Osenkov
Andrew Crawley (US - DIAGNOSTICS)
dotnet format